Theatre of politics – The Express Tribune

Landmark agreement between Russia and Ukraine
Mason dies after falling from minaret
Home
Latest
Pakistan
Business
Sci-Tech
Phones
World
Opinion
Life & Style
Sports
Blogs
Archive
Other
Since its inception, Pakistan has been characterised, to be undergoing a ‘delicate turn’
On July 19, 2022, Finance Minister Miftah Ismail appeared in an interview with renowned journalist Gharidah Farooqi in which he was seen waxing lyrical about the PDM coalition’s preparedness to remain on the path of ‘difficult decisions’ to uphold the interests of Pakistan. When asked whether this would continue as the general elections drew closer, he responded by asking whether it is worth leading the country into default simply in order to remain in power. “To hell with such elections,” said the fiery politician — triggering widespread celebration from Twitteratis — breathing a sigh of relief at the apparent tilt towards transparent, respectful, non-populist discourse. Is there more than meets the eye?
Readers of these pages are undoubtedly familiar with professional wrestling: most famously the World Wrestling Entertainment, or WWE. They are also probably aware, one would hope, that despite its genuine entertainment value, the entire program is a lie — scripted in advance to maximise viewership. This is, of course, in line with the incentive structures of the media industry in which ratings are prime currency and determine ad revenues. What most are probably unfamiliar with is the specific logic of pro-wrestling and how it perforates across several other spheres — not least of all the political.
Kayfabe is known within the pro-wrestling world as the elaborate system of deceit around which a particular endeavour is based. Wrestlers, for instance, are not competitors in the strict sense but collaborators within a closed circuit. They are perfectly aware of their ‘opponent’s’ next move, and have a specific response planned ahead of time in order to foster a broader performance for the audience — a theatrical act, in other words, that is assumed by spectators to be genuine but is, in fact, carefully choreographed.
This is not all. Preserving kayfabe is a complex art in itself, whereby occasional truths are strategically injected into the act every so often in order to keep the audience at the edge of their seats in anticipation. From a zoomed-out perspective, a process of layering can be observed in which a routinised alternation between reality and fiction takes place, but only at the behest of the puppet master, who in this case is the WWE’s board of directors.
A ‘worked shoot’, for instance, is when it appears as though the fourth wall has been torn down and the stars have broken character to engage with their fans in a sincere manner. Naturally, this too is part of the screenplay and serves a function — shock, novelty, controversy, what have you. Over time, this structured layering blurs the lines between reality and unreality in which the audience eventually gets to the point that it does not matter, one way or the other, as long as they are deriving some sort of thrill from the experience of tuning in.
As anyone with close friends or family members that occupy the corridors of power knows all too well, politics functions in a virtually identical manner. Individuals from opposing political parties will adopt toxic, adversarial, and dehumanising stances toward one another in public, only to then dine, party, and fraternise behind closed doors.
In his book titled ‘The Power Elite’, Sociologist C. Wright Mills describes this phenomenon. He highlights that these are tightly knit groupings that spend countless hours mingling with one another in exclusive spaces — expensive colleges, clubs, foreign embassies, luxury hotels, remote resorts, and even each other’s personal residences — to exchange important information, hunt for potential spouses for their children, and leverage network dynamics to uncover business opportunities and preserve their privileged status in society. Pakistan is no exception to this, as revealed in a comprehensive study of the KSE-100 by PIDE, in which it was discovered that the vast majority of individuals occupying positions in the executive boards of the corporations listed belonged to 31 primary families. Hardly a coincidence.
Since its inception, Pakistan has been characterised, at any given moment, to be undergoing a ‘delicate turn’ in which the masses cannot be attended to unless bigger concerns are first addressed. With IMF conditions once again being justified with the same rhetoric and ordinary people brought to their knees as a consequence, the nation applauds a man that purports to have ‘no choice’ but to execute them at any and all costs — all while an annual Rs2.7 trillion is extracted from the economy by elites, as per UNDP. Pakistan is indeed a welfare state for the rich, in the words of activist-academic Ammar Ali Jan.
Miftah Ismail’s ‘Pakistan First’ framing is hardly new. In fact, it could be argued that every finance minister that preceded him pledged allegiance to the same idea at one point or another, creating a smokescreen of alarmism and urgency to justify policy directions, however harmful. In the age of postmodernity, where symbols, rituals, and performances carry more weight than actual substance, does it even matter? Or have our standards fallen so low following PTI’s abysmal showing in government that it is now a moment of great joy when a politician is capable of gracefully accepting potential defeat in an election cycle — something considered the bare minimum in healthy democracies across the globe?
With over 22 million children out of school, 31% of university graduates unemployed, basic infrastructure crumbling in major cities, families unable to meet their household expenses as inflation continues to soar, temperatures in certain regions so high that lives are being lost, and men in uniform enjoying lavish privileges thanks to their massive corporate empires, the people of Pakistan are somehow expected to put aside their real material concerns and root for further inroads from imperial institutions. PDM is a coalition of parties that were responsible for creating the very conditions that made someone like Imran Khan possible. These are the same individuals that, not too long ago, hurled vicious insults at one another and laid the blame for the country’s problems at each other’s feet. But what has changed, precisely, to prompt the citizenry to wipe their slate clean and give them a fresh start?
In the words of Noam Chomsky, “The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum — even encourage the more critical and dissident views. That gives people the sense that there’s free thinking going on….”
Miftah Ismail may be a wonderful person, but he is under the thumb of the same establishmentarian politicians of yesteryear who, together with landed elites, industrial tycoons, bureaucrats, security agencies, and other loci of power, form the political economy of Pakistan. Everything that is said on live television is carefully strategised beforehand, not with the purpose of generating a ‘win’ but to continue to remain in the arena via the consent of other participants. None of this has to do with being good or bad. The power elite, including all three mainstream parties, are one big team, and you and I — fortunately or unfortunately — are simply not part of it. We could, however, present a unified front against them if we really wished to do so.
 
Published in The Express Tribune, July 25th, 2022.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
CJP remarks elicit alarms, mixed reactions
Updated Sep 14, 2022
I am a mother and Aurangzeb was my firstborn: Zara Noor shares 'traumatic' experience of stillbirth
Updated Sep 13, 2022
Actor asked mothers to prioritise their mental health as much as their physical health
You can't stop me: Khalilur Rehman Qamar blames feminists for viral leaked audio
Updated 14 hours ago
In the audio, the famous writer and a married woman were planning to meet but couldn't due to the latter's husband
Overflowing LBOD sets off alarm bells in lower Sindh
Updated 18 hours ago
Officials warn several towns to go under water if LBOD not breached near Badin
Man arrested for performing Umrah on behalf of Queen
Updated Sep 13, 2022
Security forces ‘arrested a resident of Yemeni nationality for violating the regulations and instructions for Umrah’
I am a mother and Aurangzeb was my firstborn: Zara Noor shares ‘traumatic’ experience of stillbirth
Updated Sep 13, 2022
CJP remarks elicit alarms, mixed reactions
Updated Sep 14, 2022
SCBA to issue official response to CJP's thinly-veiled remarks; PTI welcomes CJP's 'very significant' speech
Bail plea rejected in Bentley car case
Updated Sep 13, 2022
The Lahore High Court rejected an application filed for protective bail cancellation of an accused involved
Man arrested for performing Umrah on behalf of Queen
Updated Sep 13, 2022
Security forces ‘arrested a resident of Yemeni nationality for violating the regulations and instructions for Umrah’
Govt snubs Imran’s COAS extension proposal
Updated Sep 13, 2022
Asif says PTI chief making process of army chief’s appointment controversial under ‘conspiracy'
Imran meets US lobbyist in Bani Gala
Updated Sep 12, 2022
Furore on social media after Marvel introduces first Israeli superhero
Updated Sep 12, 2022
'The villain is a six-year-old Palestinian child,' a user on Twitter shared
$1b loan approval becomes harder
Updated Sep 11, 2022
World Bank may club two policy loans with many tough conditions
Demand for Kohinoor’s return gains momentum after Queen’s demise
Updated Sep 11, 2022
Netizens also demand return of Tipu Sultan's ring, Elgin Marbles, Rosetta Stone and Great Star of Africa
Imran amenable to COAS extension
Updated Sep 12, 2022
PTI chief says Nawaz, Zardari lacks moral ground to appoint next army chief
Canada announces additional $25m for Pakistan flood-affectees
PTI hits out at govt for spreading ‘religious hatred’ against Imran
Fuel charges adjustment being deferred, not waived, clarifies govt
Zardari's ancestral village at risk of inundation
Taliban confirm 'tensions' on border with Pakistan
Imran appears before JIT over terrorism charges
One On One: Hasan Rizvi
Style Anatomy: Anjiya Mithani
Style 101: 9 Lines
سب سے بڑی توہین عدالت تو وہ تھی
مقبولیت کا کامیاب سفر
گاہے گاہے باز خواں ایں قصۂ پارینہ را ، (پہلا حصہ)
احتجاج کا راستہ
منشیات اور حاضر غائب
چیف جسٹس پاکستان کا خطاب
CJP remarks elicit alarms, mixed reactions
I am a mother and Aurangzeb was my firstborn: Zara Noor shares 'traumatic' experience of stillbirth
You can't stop me: Khalilur Rehman Qamar blames feminists for viral leaked audio
Overflowing LBOD sets off alarm bells in lower Sindh
Man arrested for performing Umrah on behalf of Queen
Railway track between Lahore, Quetta and Karachi 'unfit' for use
Quality of democracy in Pakistan
The nation should rise to face the catastrophe
Indo-Pacific, Vostok 2022 & Pakistan
Monsters who rule us
Pakistan inflation in perspective
Clock is ticking…
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed or derived from. Unless otherwise stated, all content is copyrighted © 2022 The Express Tribune.

source

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.